Court Exhibit Cover Sheet & Evidence Index Templates: Formatting Guide for Trial & Small Claims

1. What is an Exhibit Cover Sheet and Evidence Index?

An Exhibit Cover Sheet is a standardized divider page placed immediately in front of each piece of physical or documentary evidence presented in trial, small claims, or arbitration hearings. Its purpose is to clearly state the exhibit identifier (e.g., "EXHIBIT A"), case caption, and brief factual description.

A Master Evidence Index (also known as an Exhibit List or Exhibit Schedule) is a comprehensive tabular inventory placed at the very front of your trial binder. It summarizes every piece of evidence in numerical or alphabetical order, along with dates, page lengths, and witness sponsorship, allowing judges to locate any record within seconds.

2. Universal Court Pleading Exhibit Format & Elements

Whether filing in state superior court or preparing for small claims, every formal exhibit cover sheet contains four core elements:

1. Court Caption Header: Identifies the court name, county or district, and division.

2. Case Docket Block: Sets forth the formal case number, plaintiff name(s), and defendant name(s).

3. Prominent Exhibit Stamp: Centered bold text designating the exhibit number (e.g., "EXHIBIT 1" or "EXHIBIT B").

4. Factual Summary: Date of the record, total page count, and authenticating witness or sponsoring party.

3. Copyable Plain-Text Master Evidence Index Template

You can use the following standard pleading text format directly inside any word processor (Microsoft Word, Google Docs) or generate a print-ready PDF using our in-browser Court Exhibit Generator:

COURT: [Insert Court Name & County/District] CASE NO.: [Insert Docket Number] PLAINTIFF(S): [Full Legal Name] vs. DEFENDANT(S): [Full Legal Name] MASTER EVIDENCE INDEX & EXHIBIT LIST EXHIBIT # DATE PAGES DESCRIPTION OF EVIDENCE --------- ---------- ----- ---------------------------------------------- Exhibit A MM/DD/YYYY 2 Lease agreement section 4 move-in deposit clause Exhibit B MM/DD/YYYY 4 Photographs of water damage beneath kitchen sink Exhibit C MM/DD/YYYY 1 Repair estimate from licensed contractor Submitted By: [ ] Plaintiff [ ] Defendant Signature: __________________________ Date: __________________

4. Bates Stamping and Numbering Multi-Page Exhibits

In complex litigation and document-heavy arbitration, courts and discovery rules mandate Bates Stamping—the sequential numbering of every page in an exhibit packet (e.g., PLTF-0001 to PLTF-0450).

Bates numbers are traditionally stamped in the bottom right corner of each page. They allow attorneys and the judge to refer to specific lines on specific pages during oral examination (e.g., "Your Honor, directing the witness to Page PLTF-0034, lines 12 through 18").

5. Organizing Trial Binders for the Judge and Opposing Counsel

To prepare a flawless trial presentation: Use sturdy 3-ring binders with front cover inserts displaying your case caption. Place the Master Evidence Index as page 1. Insert physical exhibit divider tabs matching your exhibit letters or numbers. Ensure the judge, witness, and opposing counsel each have an identical binder with synchronized page numbering.

Frequently Asked Questions

Explore Related Legal Guides